Lawsuit Filed to Declare Legislation that Reduces Financial Aid for Student Loans Unconstitutional

Cuts in federal student loan programs resulting from recent legislation could significantly affect the college education of millions of Americans. The legislation cuts $12 billion from financial aid programs. Student loan consolidation is also affected and will impact students looking to consolidate high interest loans. This is not good news for students or parents of students.

The Deficit Reduction Act of 2005, S. 1932, that was signed into law on Feb. 8 by President Bush continues to come under fire. Another lawsuit to declare that the legislation is unconstitutional was filed April 28 by Rep. John Conyers Jr., D-MI, ranking member on the House Judiciary Committee, who was joined in the suit by 10 Congress members including Rep. George Miller, D-CA, ranking member, House Committee on Education and the Workforce.

The first lawsuit to challenge the bills constitutionality was filed Feb. 13 by Jim Zeigler, Republican activist and Mobile, AL, elder law attorney. Public Citizen, a Washington-based nonprofit consumer advocacy group, on March 21 filed its own suit seeking to declare the Deficit Reduction Acts unconstitutionality.

Different Versions of the Legislation

According to Democrats the House and Senate passed different versions of the legislation, therefore rendering the bill unconstitutional. The House passed a version of the bill that included funding for 36 months of durable medical equipment and the Senates version contained only 13 months. As a constitutional requirement, both the House and Senate must sign identical versions of a bill prior to it being signed into law by the president.

Once again the Administration is playing fast and loose with the Constitution. Anyone who has passed the sixth grade knows that before a bill can become a law, both Houses of Congress must approve it. That the Bush Administration is now saying otherwise underscores the Constitutional crisis we are facing in this country, said Conyers in an April 27 press statement released from his office. Over 200 years of legal precedent dictate that such discrepancies can be handled through simply refiling the paperwork, or re-voting the whole bill. Because the bill cuts billions of dollars to the Nations most needy, the Republican leadership prevented a re-vote at all costs.

Conyers suit names anyone responsible for the budget, which includes Secretary of Education Margaret Spellings and President Bush along with other parties responsible for enacting the budget cuts required by the Deficit Reduction Act, according to Democratic aides.

With his lawsuit, Conyers asks for the entire bill to be declared unconstitutional and, therefore, not law, Democratic aides said. The lawsuit asks that an interim restraining order be put in place to prohibit enactment of the law.

Republican leaders were in such a rush to ram this bill through Congress and get the President to sign it that they violated the Constitution in the process, said Miller in the press statement. And they were in a rush because this was a very, very bad bill. They wanted to spend as little time as possible having to explain their backwards priorities -- like cutting $12 billion from financial aid programs for college students -- to their constituents.

The lawsuit was filed in the Eastern District Court of Michigan, case No. 2:06-CV-11972. Judge Nancy Edmunds is scheduled to preside over the case; however, it is not known when the case will be heard.

Education is the foundation on which any great civilization is built and this is certainly the case in the United States. When educational opportunities are taken away it can erode this foundation. That is why we need to take action to declare the Deficit Reduction Act unconstitutional. I believe an education is the best investment anyone can make and I am dedicated to helping individuals pursue their educational dreams by making college funding as easy as possible.

Daniel Rivera is President of Federal Student Loan Solutions and a veteran of the student loan industry. For more information visit their website http://www.fsls.net

Class-action Lawsuit Filed Over Bush Tax Refund Program
According to lawyers, millions of small businesses and low-income taxpayers will be excluded from a Bush administration tax refund program.A class-action lawsuit has been filed by lawyers in regards to a Treasury Department plan in which the public stopped paying a 3% federal excise tax on long-distance phone calls as of July 31. The tax collected ...

Student Loan Consolidation - The Best Debt Relief Opportunity For Every Student
Student loans are loans taken by the students to fund their education. These loans are not grants or scholarships to the students. They are just like any other unsecured loans. Only difference is that the repayment period starts after six months of the student completing the course for which he has taken the loan. This gives him ample time to settl...

Getting Rid of Tax Debts in Bankruptcy
Ask ten people if you can discharge tax debts in bankruptcy and you will get ten different answers. The correct answer is that you can, but only if certain tests are met.Getting Rid of Tax Debts in BankruptcyBankruptcy is the great financial white board for Americans. It essentially serves as a get out of financial jail card, a chance to start ove...

Federal Family Education Loan Consolidation Helps Students Save
The Federal Family Education Loan Program (FFELP) helps students and their families save money by bundling multiple student loans into a single student loan, locking in the new student loan at a low interest rate and offering benefits in the form of interest rate reductions. H.R. 5, a bill recently passed by the House of Representatives and now...

How to Make the Best Choice of a Student Loans Company
In the past college and university education proved so expensive With Students having big financial burdens and debts to pay as they struggled through their education. There had to be an alternative. Many companies started cropping up to try and solve this problem. Ever since the establishment of a Student Loans Company operation , many students ha...

A Private Student Loan is an Alternative to Fund Your Education
Many times we look forward to accomplishing our dreams one of them being education. Education is very expensive according to whichever lever you may be at, from high school to college education and universities. The higher you go the more expensive it becomes and the more your future takes a good shape. Therefore, expensive is a terminology that yo...

What You Need to Know Concerning Student Loans FAFSA
FAFSA is one of the terms you have or may come across when you look for information about the student loans. FAFSA stands for Free Application for Federal Student Aid. As the terms suggests it is one of the federal student aid program available that students apply for free. It may also be used to apply for aid from other sources like your school or...